| Player | Season | DOB | Pos | Height | Nationatlity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kendrix Brown | 2009/10 | 29 Apr 1990 | G | 191 cm (6- 3 ft) | USA |
| Kyle Gaillard | 2009/10 | 15 Apr 1991 | F | 203 cm (6- 8 ft) | USA |
| Steven Hess | 2009/10 | 03 Mar 1987 | F | 208 cm (6-10 ft) | USA |
| Doug Howard | 2009/10 | 01 Feb 1991 | G | 175 cm (5- 9 ft) | USA |
| Marcus Kitts | 2009/10 | 31 Jan 1989 | F/C | 206 cm (6- 9 ft) | USA |
| JohnMark Ludwick | 2009/10 | 30 Dec 1988 | F | 203 cm (6- 8 ft) | USA |
| Sean McCurdy | 2009/10 | 24 Jul 1986 | G | 185 cm (6- 1 ft) | USA |
| Quinn McDowell | 2009/10 | 13 Jan 1990 | G/F | 196 cm (6- 5 ft) | USA |
| Matt McFadden | 2009/10 | 28 Oct 1987 | G | 188 cm (6- 2 ft) | USA |
| Andrew Pavloff | 2009/10 | 14 Dec 1990 | F | 206 cm (6- 9 ft) | USA |
| Matt Rum | 2009/10 | 09 Nov 1989 | G | 193 cm (6- 4 ft) | USA |
| David Schneider | 2009/10 | 18 May 1987 | G | 191 cm (6- 3 ft) | USA |
| Danny Sumner | 2009/10 | 06 Dec 1987 | F/C | 201 cm (6- 7 ft) | USA |
| date | type | home | visitor | result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 Nov 2009 | Non conference | Connecticut | College of William & Mary | 75 - 66 |
| 15 Nov 2009 | Non conference | Harvard | College of William & Mary | 87 - 85 OT |
| 19 Nov 2009 | Non conference | College of William & Mary | Richmond | 78 - 71 |
| 21 Nov 2009 | Non conference | Manhattan | College of William & Mary | 70 - 75 |
| 25 Nov 2009 | Non conference | College of William & Mary | Hampton | 62 - 61 |
| 28 Nov 2009 | Non conference | Wake Forest | College of William & Mary | 68 - 78 |
| 02 Dec 2009 | Non conference | College of William & Mary | Longwood | 84 - 65 |
| 05 Dec 2009 | CAA | College of William & Mary | VCU | 75 - 74 |
| 22 Dec 2009 | Non conference | Radford | College of William & Mary | 68 - 70 |
| 30 Dec 2009 | Non conference | Maryland | College of William & Mary | 77 - 83 |
| 02 Jan 2010 | CAA | Hofstra | College of William & Mary | 47 - 48 |
| 04 Jan 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | UNC Wilmington | 61 - 62 |
| 06 Jan 2010 | CAA | Delaware | College of William & Mary | 73 - 74 OT |
| 09 Jan 2010 | CAA | Drexel | College of William & Mary | 48 - 73 |
| 14 Jan 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | James Madison | 85 - 78 |
| 16 Jan 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Hofstra | 73 - 66 |
| 20 Jan 2010 | CAA | VCU | College of William & Mary | 81 - 59 |
| 23 Jan 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Old Dominion | 55 - 58 |
| 27 Jan 2010 | CAA | James Madison | College of William & Mary | 65 - 63 |
| 31 Jan 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Drexel | 54 - 51 |
| 03 Feb 2010 | CAA | Old Dominion | College of William & Mary | 61 - 42 |
| 06 Feb 2010 | CAA | Georgia State | College of William & Mary | 56 - 59 |
| 10 Feb 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Delaware | 67 - 54 |
| 13 Feb 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Northeastern | 53 - 52 |
| 16 Feb 2010 | CAA | George Mason | College of William & Mary | 60 - 63 |
| 19 Feb 2010 | Non conference | Iona | College of William & Mary | 69 - 53 |
| 24 Feb 2010 | CAA | College of William & Mary | Towson | 77 - 83 |
| 27 Feb 2010 | CAA | UNC Wilmington | College of William & Mary | 51 - 62 |
| 06 Mar 2010 | Tournament | College of William & Mary | James Madison | 70 - 65 |
| 07 Mar 2010 | Tournament | Northeastern | College of William & Mary | 45 - 47 |
| 08 Mar 2010 | Tournament | Old Dominion | College of William & Mary | 60 - 53 |
| 16 Mar 2010 | NIT 1/16 final | North Carolina | College of William & Mary | 80 - 72 |